Who Should Enforce Protections for Farmworkers? L&C Law Professor Weighs In

Juliet Stumpf, an immigration law and crimmigration law expert, joined NPR’s Here & Now to discuss a Supreme Court case that could change how the federal government enforces labor protections for agricultural workers.

November 18, 2026

A dispute over working conditions at a New Jersey family farm has made its way to the U.S. Supreme Court, raising questions about who should enforce federal labor laws and what a ruling could mean for agricultural workers across the country.

Juliet Stumpf, Edmund O. Belsheim Professor of Law, joined host Robin Young on NPR’s Here & Now to discuss the case, Department of Labor v. Sun Valley Orchards. Stumpf is a scholar of immigration law and crimmigration law, the intersection of immigration and criminal law.

The case arose after the Department of Labor fined a farm more than $550,000 for alleged violations involving housing, meals, and transportation for temporary immigrant workers.

The farm denied the allegations, arguing that the case belonged in federal court rather than in the Department of Labor’s administrative proceedings.

Stumpf explained that requiring federal courts to handle these cases could make enforcement slower, more expensive, and less effective.

“So we would potentially lose that kind of expertise if the Labor Department were forced to go to the federal courts,” she said.

But the stakes go beyond how labor violations are handled. Stumpf noted that enforcing protections for temporary immigrant workers also protects U.S. workers and employers who comply with labor regulations.

“The Labor Department’s job in particular is to protect these workers, and especially U.S. domestic workers, by preventing a race to the bottom in wages and working conditions,” Stumpf said.

The justices also appeared to be weighing a broader question: Is this a case about immigration or employment? As Stumpf explained, that distinction could help determine the Labor Department’s authority to protect workers.

More Stories

Presenters at the 2026 Business Law Fall Forum.
Prof. Klonoff teaches a Lewis & Clark Law class.
Cole (left) speaking at the Data Centers: New Kids on the Block panel