Huffman Award 2026 Recipient of the Year: Professor David Schraub

The Huffman Award 2026 was given to Professor David Schraub for his article “The Jurisprudence of Constitutional Entitlement,” which addresses his growing “frustration at recent trends in the Supreme Court’s (and some lower courts’) jurisprudence.” 

November 19, 2026
Assistant Professor David Schraub
Assistant Professor David Schraub
Credit: Nina Johnson

This year’s annual Huffman Scholarship Award recognizes Associate Professor of Law David Schraub, for his outstanding scholarly contribution with his paper titled “The Jurisprudence of Constitutional Entitlement.” The paper was published in the William & Mary Bill of Rights Journal last fall.

This is the second time Schraub has won the Huffman Award. His article “Sadomasochistic Judging” was recognized in 2022.

As a constitutional law expert, Prof. Schraub’s article specifically addresses his growing “frustration at recent trends in the Supreme Court’s (and some lower courts’) jurisprudence.” He explained that constitutional doctrines today “consistently yield to the desired end result, rather than the other way around. The consequence is that the doctrinal rules are becoming increasingly incoherent—but worse, that incoherence doesn’t matter because the Court is unabashed in creating new exceptions and carveouts to patch over what would otherwise be gaping logical or practical holes in the rules it is nominally announcing.”

Based on these observations, Prof. Schraub introduced the concept of “constitutional entitlement” in the article. He wrote, a “constitutional entitlement is a practice that the government is not just allowed but entitled to do; if the practice appears to violate more specific constitutional restrictions, the restrictions must yield.” Across the judicial landscape, the problem caused by constitutional entitlement is “not necessarily the bottom line results; it is that the paths the Court was taking to get there are frankly slapdash.”

In the article, there are detailed examples of the troublesome judicial “bad acts.” For example, the Court has treated a state’s entitlement to engage in partisan gerrymandering as effectively trumping rules against racial discrimination. In other cases, the Court has elevated an entitlement to impose capital punishment over and above specific constitutional protections against cruel and unusual punishments (even in circumstances where a particular mode of execution may questionably result in excruciating pain).

Schraub further explained his thinking about judges’ “bad acts”. “Bad behavior is paired with an increasing sense of entitlement on the part of judges – a perceived right to be adored, or at least not criticized, and a palpable frustration that the bar and the public did not see them as the exemplars of legal interpretation they self-identified as.” The “fact that many esteemed lawyers and judges – of a wide range of backgrounds and political priors – were raising warnings about increasing lawlessness from the high court was not taken as a valuable feedback signal that something had gone awry, it rather generated very public resentment on the part of the Justices furious that they were not receiving the genuflection they thought was their due.”

To Prof. Schraub, “law is a discipline – it is an area of study and practice with collective norms and standards of conduct and analysis.” He emphasized that the legal profession’s disciplinary and participatory nature “hardly means all lawyers will agree on contested issues. But it should mean that some respect ought to be paid for the wisdom of crowds and the collective wisdom of the legal community.”

He notes that while “judges (one hopes) are generally very smart and very learned lawyers, there is no reason to think that the nine Supreme Court Justices are the nine smartest and nine most learned lawyers in America. When the legal community as a whole signals that something has gone awry, good, prudent judges should take that feedback more seriously.”

More Stories

U.S. Supreme Court exterior
Presenters at the 2026 Business Law Fall Forum.
Prof. Klonoff teaches a Lewis & Clark Law class.